Boeing 747 zletel s steze

Ytbnd

Guru
2. mar 2010
16.633
5.806
113
Švicarski ATC, tudi Japonski ATC (torej ne neki "Balkanci") je 1.5 leta prej skoraj povzročil tragedijo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_Japan_Airlines_mid-air_incident

TCAS je opozarjal, da se vektorja (tenzora) poti sekata


Če se oglasi TCAS alarm, ima pilot nekje do max. 35s časa da ukrepa

Vanz
Natančnost navigacije je brezhibna
Gps jamming, pa ravno ti si dal nekje v temi link.
 

Ytbnd

Guru
2. mar 2010
16.633
5.806
113
2011 ponovno Švicarski atc, "igre brez meja" med ch atc in tcas ra


tu piše da sta se letali zgrešili za 30 m
  • 2011 Fribourg near-collision, involving Germanwings Airbus A319 Flight 2529 and Hahn-Air-Lines Raytheon Premier I Flight 201. Air traffic control at Geneva allowed flight 2529 to sink to flight level 250 (25,000 feet [7,620 m]) but entered flight level 280 (28,000 feet [8,534 m]) as usual for handover to traffic control at Zürich. Air traffic control at Zürich allowed flight 201 to climb to flight level 270 (27,000 feet [8,230 m]). This triggered a resolution advisory (RA) for the Airbus to sink and for the Raytheon to climb which was followed by both aircraft. Nine seconds later Geneva instructed the Raytheon to sink to flight level 260 (26,000 feet [7,925 m]) which they then followed. It led to a situation where both planes passed at 100 feet (30 m) minimum distance. Shortly later the Raytheon was lower than the Airbus and TCAS issued a reversal RA for the Airbus to climb and for the Raytheon to sink.[4]
 

VanZ

Guru
1. feb 2008
2.813
2.034
113
Vanz

Gps jamming, pa ravno ti si dal nekje v temi link.
Jamming (izguba signala) in spoofing (napačna pozicija/čas) sta prisotna na znanih območjih, drugje deluje gps zanesljivo in natančno.
Hecno je, ko dobiš zaradi napačne pozicije na 35,000ft sredi morja med Sudanom in Savdsko arabijo GPWS "terrain pull up" in naenkrat celotno terensko karto na navigacijskem zalonu rdečo, kot da si pod vsem terenom.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: novaa

SJTV1

eV12
18. jul 2007
19.115
1.167
113
www.adriamedia.si
2011 ponovno Švicarski atc, "igre brez meja" med ch atc in tcas ra


tu piše da sta se letali zgrešili za 30 m
  • 2011 Fribourg near-collision, involving Germanwings Airbus A319 Flight 2529 and Hahn-Air-Lines Raytheon Premier I Flight 201. Air traffic control at Geneva allowed flight 2529 to sink to flight level 250 (25,000 feet [7,620 m]) but entered flight level 280 (28,000 feet [8,534 m]) as usual for handover to traffic control at Zürich. Air traffic control at Zürich allowed flight 201 to climb to flight level 270 (27,000 feet [8,230 m]). This triggered a resolution advisory (RA) for the Airbus to sink and for the Raytheon to climb which was followed by both aircraft. Nine seconds later Geneva instructed the Raytheon to sink to flight level 260 (26,000 feet [7,925 m]) which they then followed. It led to a situation where both planes passed at 100 feet (30 m) minimum distance. Shortly later the Raytheon was lower than the Airbus and TCAS issued a reversal RA for the Airbus to climb and for the Raytheon to sink.[4]
Tule (in v post višje primeru) je neposredni vzrok bližnjega srečanja (ali nesreče) na strani pilota, ki ni upošteval TCAS, kontrolor pa je bil le tisti, ki je zaradi napake povzročil pogoje za nastanek take situacije. Kontrolor je, v končni fazi, le svetovalec - končno besedo ima pilot. TCAS dela brez napak. kontrolorji ne.
 

matej_

Guru
25. okt 2007
2.096
633
113
1.jpg