Znanstveni članki

kravakonj

Fizikalc
30. okt 2012
5.215
0
36
še en članek o zgornji raziskavi:
http://www.mhpbooks.com/john-b...atively-little/
Citat:
But, as many commentators have pointed out, Bohannon’s sting has some major problems itself—most glaringly, the fact that he didn’t submit the paper to any traditional subscription journals. Which means that this supposed indictment of open access publishing (which it will inevitably be taken as, despite Bohannon’s pretty feeble objections otherwise) gives no sense of how blameless traditional publishing is on these counts.
Tudi mene je to zmotilo: ni fore v preverjanju petorazrednih publikacij, tovrstno raziskavo bo moral narediti na publikacijah, ki so kao kredibilne.
 

jurek1973

Guru
3. sep 2007
4.183
1.171
113
Postavlja se še eno vprašanje:
A je Bohannon sploh izvedel to raziskavo ali se jo je enostavno izmislil?