Lepote multikulturnosti 4

ferdo

Guru
3. sep 2007
10.414
3.847
113
Ljubljana
hmpg.net
To je halal, kako pa izgleda kosher klanje?
AI pravi takole:
Halal and kosher slaughter are both methods of preparing meat according to religious dietary laws in Islam and Judaism, respectively. While there are similarities between the two methods, there are also some differences:
  1. Religious Practices:
    • Halal: Halal slaughter is performed by a Muslim who recites a dedication to God (Allah) before making the cut. The act is performed in the name of God.
    • Kosher: Kosher slaughter (shechita) is performed by a Jewish individual trained as a Shochet. The act does not involve a religious dedication or blessing during the slaughter process.
  2. Knife and Cut:
    • Halal: The knife used in halal slaughter must be very sharp, similar to kosher slaughter. In halal slaughter, the cut is made swiftly across the throat, cutting the trachea, esophagus, carotid arteries, and jugular veins.
    • Kosher: The knife used in kosher slaughter, called a Chalef, must also be extremely sharp and free of imperfections. The cut is made across the throat to sever the major arteries and veins, causing rapid loss of consciousness.
  3. Animal Health and Inspection:
    • Halal: Similar to kosher practices, the animal must be healthy and free from disease. Halal requires that the animal be alive and healthy at the time of slaughter.
    • Kosher: The animal must be healthy and free from disease as well. Kosher laws also mandate the inspection of the animal's organs post-slaughter to ensure no abnormalities or diseases that would render the meat non-kosher.
  4. Blood Removal:
    • Halal and Kosher: Both halal and kosher methods require the draining of the blood from the animal, as consuming blood is prohibited in both Islamic and Jewish dietary laws.
While there are similarities in the methods and the emphasis on humane slaughter and religious adherence, the differences lie in the specific religious protocols, prayers, and the individuals who are allowed to perform the slaughter according to their respective religious laws.

Ni razlik,razen molitve, pred, med in po klanju. Obe "metodi" povzročita hitro izgubo krvi, ki je "nečista" po obeh naukih.
 

Daniel

Guru
21. dec 2007
5.485
2.956
113
Glede na to kaj vse ne poslušamo od inšpektorjev pri nas, kako mora vse biti tip top, krava niti šepati ne sme, če gre v klavnico, ker takoj dobiš kazen, potem pa taki prizori pri halal klanju. Saj ne veš kaj bi si mislil. Ko bi jo vsaj omamili prej, a ne, kar na živo.
 

piagolo

Guru
22. nov 2009
6.789
3.510
113
Glede na to kaj vse ne poslušamo od inšpektorjev pri nas, kako mora vse biti tip top, krava niti šepati ne sme, če gre v klavnico, ker takoj dobiš kazen, potem pa taki prizori pri halal klanju. Saj ne veš kaj bi si mislil. Ko bi jo vsaj omamili prej, a ne, kar na živo.
Ooo, tudi tja pridemo odvzemat!
 

corsol

Guru
11. mar 2010
2.878
903
113
Glede na to kaj vse ne poslušamo od inšpektorjev pri nas, kako mora vse biti tip top, krava niti šepati ne sme, če gre v klavnico, ker takoj dobiš kazen, potem pa taki prizori pri halal klanju. Saj ne veš kaj bi si mislil. Ko bi jo vsaj omamili prej, a ne, kar na živo.
No kakšne domače koline znajo bit kar podobne halalu, ....pač tradicija....pa to ....
Sam to itak ne spada v to temo.
 
  • Všeč mi je
Reactions: bizi in aljoman